Listening closely: Comparing Device-Based and Expert-Based Bird Monitoring
(2) E.C.O. - Institute of Ecology, Lakesidepark B07b, 9020 Klagenfurt am Wörthersee, Carinthia, Austria
Abstract
Reliable bird monitoring is an important component of biodiversity assessment. Birds are widely used as indicators of ecological condition because they respond sensitively to habitat characteristics, land management practices, and environmental change. In recent years, autonomous recording units (ARUs) have gained increasing attention as a potentially cost-effective complement or alternative to traditional expert-based field surveys. Combined with AI-supported species detection, ARUs enable standardized and continuous recording over extended periods. However, questions remain regarding their accuracy, precision, and comparability of acoustic monitoring in relation to surveys conducted by experienced field ornithologists.
This contribution examines the performance of ARUs for bird monitoring based on preliminary results from two projects, BioMonitor4CAP and BiodiverCity. The main focus is on comparisons of conventional point-count surveys conducted by field ornithologists against acoustic recordings collected at the same locations, times and survey dates. In addition, preliminary findings from an acoustic monitoring site in Villach will illustrate the application of continuous acoustic monitoring in an urban context. The study covers different sites and habitat types across Austria and evaluates to what extent the approaches provide comparable information on species occurrence and bird community composition.
Particular attention is given to differences in detection performance, confidence, and precision of acoustic species identification, as well as the methodological advantages and limitations of expert-based versus device-based monitoring. This includes considerations such as temporal coverage, observer dependence, data processing requirements, and the potential for automated long-term monitoring.
Together, the examples provide insights into the advantages and current limitations of ARUs and their potential role as a complementary tool for biodiversity monitoring programs.
If this happens again, please get in touch with us.